Pace and Cap  - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up

Pace and Cap - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up (http://paceandcap.com/forums/index.php)
-   Sartin Methodology Handicapping 101 (102 ...) (http://paceandcap.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=116)
-   -   Why NOT Maidens? (http://paceandcap.com/forums/showthread.php?t=8982)

For The Lead 01-23-2013 11:21 PM

Why NOT Maidens?
 
In all probability, this will not be a real popular topic, but I'm putting it up here anyway. The idea is for this to be educational, so here it goes.

In general, the Sartin Methodology dismisses maiden races, but should you?

I'm aware that most people avoid maidens like the plague. But why? Some of the best plays I find come in maidens races.
Like any other type of race, you have to understand the race that you have in front of you.
Now I’m not suggesting that you bet a maiden race that is full of first time starters, however, first time starters don’t win that large of a percentage of maiden races, so as long as there is just a couple of them I don’t mind. I can just throw them out.

The other thing to take note of is, the number of lifetime races a maiden has. A maiden that continues to run without winning, learns to lose! Many times these types of maidens are the ones that are bet down to favoritism because they show good running lines, having run second and third several times.

Also, I’m not a fan of maidens scheduled to run on the turf. In fact, I definitely avoid those races. Actually, I prefer sprint races, but sometimes routes will do just fine.

Finally, in general, if you are looking for the best speed ratings and best third fractions, perhaps maidens are the wrong place to look.

Looking at 2 consecutive years of maiden races, both maiden special weight and maiden claiming that consisted of more than 22,000 races, the following were my findings:

About 52% of maiden races were won by the horse that was running 1st or 2nd at the first call.
About 63% of maiden races were won by the horse that was running 1st or 2nd at the second call.


Maidens, especially young maidens, haven’t learned how to run yet. Many of them don’t take kindly to rating. They just want to come out of the gate and run as fast and as far as they can. So the statistics bear this out. What you should be looking for is the horse that is the fastest early. Many times this horse establishes a lead and just goes on with it.

When it comes to line selection, unless a maiden won and got disqualified, you obviously don’t have winning lines to choose from. Therefore you are left with lines where the horse may have run 2nd or 3rd. You also have to consider lines where the horse was running 1st or 2nd at the first call, even if it fades from there. My line selection procedure in maiden races is no different than any other type of race.

I looked at the maiden races from the last couple of days at the tracks I like to follow. There were 10 of them. Three of these races did not produce the winner from among my contenders. Some of the winning races had only 2 contenders. Some of them had short prices such as $6 or $7, but then there were others that make it all worthwhile, just like in any other type of race.

The following posts will show the screen shots from the various races. I will also offer some commentary.

For The Lead 01-23-2013 11:26 PM

PRX race 3 on 1.20.13
 
4 Attachment(s)
There were only two contenders here, so for those who bet 2 horses per race there really isn't anything to do. Either play or pass based on the odds.

The winner, #3, paid $6.60.

For The Lead 01-23-2013 11:34 PM

TP race 2 1.20.13
 
4 Attachment(s)
Here is another race with just 2 contenders. If you must bet 2 horses, your only decision here is to play or pass based on odds. If you are looking for a 1 horse bet, take particular note of the the running lines and "RS" for the 2 contenders, that will point you in the right direction.

Then you can follow all the things I have marked.

The winner, #3, paid $7.20.

For The Lead 01-23-2013 11:37 PM

TP race 4 1.20.13
 
My contenders did not produce the winner of this race.

For The Lead 01-23-2013 11:51 PM

TP race 6 1.20.13
 
4 Attachment(s)
Here is the race that makes it worthwhile.
I have 5 contenders.
Take note of the various markings that lead to the winner.

The winner, #6, paid $37.40.

For The Lead 01-24-2013 12:00 AM

TP race 9th 1.20.13
 
4 Attachment(s)
This is another nice paying winner.

Start by taking note of the running lines and "RS".
Then the "TPR" section certainly shows this winner's early domination.
Again, on the "segments" screen, the winner's early domination is clear.

The winner, #3, paid $11.60.
Attachment 33489

For The Lead 01-24-2013 12:07 AM

LRL race 5 1.21.13
 
4 Attachment(s)
Another nice priced winner.

Looking at the lines, it is easy to find the early horse, not just in the running lines, but in the "RS" designations. Also, two of these contenders are running back for today's claiming price while the third is moving up a couple of classes.

The "segments" screen also points out what a clear early advantage the winner had.

The winner, #4, paid $13.00.

Bill V. 01-24-2013 12:09 AM

On the lead in the turn
 
Good lesson FTL thank you

I think your showing a real stong factor.
Your commentary of the horse on the lead in the first two fractions
supports the idea of maidens who struggle on the turn
and lose all chance to the lead horses


Here is Doc's comments on maidens from Pace Makes The Race
in the turn time article page 336

"Some horses,especially maidens, tend to loaf on the turn. This comes from fear of the turn based on inexperience and the inability to change leads.
(stepping off the proper rear foot) Maidens who can run superior turn times are frequent winners next time out"

For The Lead 01-24-2013 12:10 AM

LRL race 9 1.21.13
 
My contenders did not produce the winner of this race.

For The Lead 01-24-2013 12:23 AM

Prx 1.21.13 1.21.13
 
4 Attachment(s)
Here is another race with just 2 contenders. Again, two horse players have one choice, play or pass.

Notice that these two horses are close on "RS" with one horse being "P5" and the other "P6".

There is a possibility that the difference in times and rankings are a result of one horse being rated on an 8.3f race, while the other horse is being rated on a 9.0f race.

The winner, #2, paid $7.20.

For The Lead 01-24-2013 12:38 AM

PRX race 4 1.21.13
 
4 Attachment(s)
This is an interesting race for the following reason.
THERE IS NOT AN EARLY HORSE AMONG THE CONTENDERS!
Just look at the running lines.
What I'm going to say next applies to ALL TYPES of races. When you end up with nothing but pressers and closers among you contenders, one of them will rank #1 early. One of them will show best on the F1 section of the segments screen. One of them will show fastest on EPR on the TPR screen.
Does this mean that is the early horse in the race?
ABSOLUTELY NOT!!

Early horses are early horses.
OTHER THAN early horses are OTHER THAN early!!!

So in this race there is no early horse to "zero in on", even though the winner showed best on F1 on the segments screen. In this race the BL/BL may be the right place to look. In this case it was. The winner actually came from off the pace to win the race.

One last note. Check the class on the running lines screen. The winner is the only horse among the contenders that is dropping down a couple of classes for this race. This is always a help to maidens.

The winner, #4, paid $6.20.

For The Lead 01-24-2013 12:39 AM

PRX race 6 1.21.13
 
My contenders did not produce the winner of this race.

For The Lead 01-24-2013 01:02 AM

Recap
 
So just to recap, the ten races mentioned here were run on 2 consecutive days, at 3 different tracks on 2 different surfaces.

The total return of the 7 winners comes to $89.20.
Some would have been "high odds" bets, while some may have been "low odds" bets.
Either way I'm sure you can see these were profitable races.

polambi 01-24-2013 11:06 AM

For The Lead, thanks for a great post about maidens. A lot of us do avoid those maidens. You are totally right about that. But I recognize that there are opportunities there, since there is never a shortage of maiden races, and their mutual is not that bad, compared to the non-maiden races that are more predictable by the public, and therefore overbet.
Thanks to your post, I am willing to take the dive. I will let you know when I catch my first big one. Have a good day.
Paul

Bill V. 01-25-2013 07:06 AM

anybody
 
Did anybody work yeaterdays Santa Anita maiden race using FTL's outline

If you had you would have been very happy
The track was wet/fast and no turf

Bill

alydar_ David 01-25-2013 10:10 AM

I'd be interested in seeing your stats for EP regardless of running style.

For sprints, I suspect you'll find significantly more winners showed a top EP rating in MCL than MSW.

For The Lead 01-26-2013 12:44 AM

3 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill V. (Post 88399)
Did anybody work yeaterdays Santa Anita maiden race using FTL's outline

If you had you would have been very happy
The track was wet/fast and no turf

Bill

You're right, Bill.

I wasn't going to post the maiden races from SA yesterday because it really isn't a study of what it takes from a running style point of view, which is how I started this thread.
However, it is still worthwhile posting from a "contender selection" point of view. I'm just going to post up the "original" screen for each race.

RACE #2....none of my contenders won this race.

RACE #4....here's the screen shot. The winner, #12, paid $35.60.

Attachment 33523

RACE #5....here's the screen shot. The winner, #3, paid $3.40.

Attachment 33524

RACE #8....here's the screen shot. The winner, #11, paid $16.00.
Attachment 33525

For those not keeping track, this makes 10 winners from 14 races with a total return of $144.20.

JIMBOB1002 01-26-2013 09:37 AM

LRL 9th Race
 
2 Attachment(s)
Thought I would jump in with this one
from yesterday. I only had 2 contenders.
I wanted to thank FTL this was an excellent post
he started.

JIMBOB1002 01-26-2013 09:39 AM

1 Attachment(s)
***

Bill V. 02-01-2013 09:43 PM

Look for it
 
4 Attachment(s)
It took a while I had some success with maiden earlys but I wanted to wait for the LONE E8
I got it tonight race 6 from Penn

I only bet $2 but 14/1 is nice
Attachment 33586

Attachment 33584


Attachment 33583

Attachment 33585

Ted Craven 02-01-2013 09:57 PM

Bill,

Once the Running Style formula is tuned up a bit, would it be helpful to show the array of Running Styles for each race (and Early Speed Points) in the My Races tool so you could search for, for example, Maiden Races with exactly 1 E8 ?

Ted

vderdak 02-01-2013 10:44 PM

I hit him too, also the one at SA today, same thing, lone early at a bit over 10-1 odds in the final race.

polambi 02-01-2013 11:06 PM

Great catch on this maiden win, Bill V!
I have an eye on those maidens too.

For The Lead 02-01-2013 11:22 PM

You beat me to the punch!
 
Great job bill.

I was going to post this race, so I got all my screens together and marked the important areas so everyone could follow along. When I got to the the thread....there was your post!!! Oh well, as long as somebody put it up here for everyone to see, that's all that matters. :)

And congratulations to those that hit this horse or other maidens like it! Good Job.

I finished my post with the following:

In Las Vegas there is a old saying. Winner, winner, chicken dinner.
Well, make that a STEAK DINNER!!!!

lone speed 02-01-2013 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill V. (Post 88567)
It took a while I had some success with maiden earlys but I wanted to wait for the LONE E8
I got it tonight race 6 from Penn

I only bet $2 but 14/1 is nice
Attachment 33586

Attachment 33584


Attachment 33583

Attachment 33585


Bill....

It might be interesting if we can cut off the paceline from #4 Kohl and we come with a virtual line of Kohl only running a 5 furlong race......The Hat talked many times of using virtual lines....so I don't see why we can't come up with one in this situation....

We would use the same beaten lengths but for the finish beaten lengths, we use 5 lengths as the final beaten lengths....

i.e.
5 furlongs....22.9 47.7 100.5 beaten lengths use 0 0 .hd and 5 lengths

depending on what programs you are using...

thoromation--no speed ratings required...

others----use what a 5 lengths finish behind a time of 100.5 correlates at the current track at Penn for 5 furlongs...

I am sure that #4 Kohl would be in the top of readouts....:)


Good skills

For The Lead 02-02-2013 12:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lone speed (Post 88583)
Bill....

It might be interesting if we can cut off the paceline from #4 Kohl and we come with a virtual line of Kohl only running a 5 furlong race......The Hat talked many times of using virtual lines....so I don't see why we can't come up with one in this situation....

We would use the same beaten lengths but for the finish beaten lengths, we use 5 lengths as the final beaten lengths....

i.e.
5 furlongs....22.9 47.7 100.5 beaten lengths use 0 0 .hd and 5 lengths

depending on what programs you are using...

thoromation--no speed ratings required...

others----use what a 5 lengths finish behind a time of 100.5 correlates at the current track at Penn for 5 furlongs...

I am sure that #4 Kohl would be in the top of readouts....:)


Good skills

I know you asked this question of Bill V., but since I started this thread and since the whole idea behind the thread was identifying maiden winners by their early speed, regardless of finish, what you are suggesting would defeat the entire purpose of the thread.

And speaking of "on top", the $30 winner in Bill V.'s most recent post was "on top" at the first fraction, "on top" at the second fraction" and "on top" at the second call. The purpose behind this thread was to show how horses that are "on top" at these positions of the race are oft times "ON TOP" at the end of the race....regardless of their previous finish.

lone speed 02-02-2013 12:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by For The Lead (Post 88586)
I know you asked this question of Bill V., but since I started this thread and since the whole idea behind the thread was identifying maiden winners by their early speed, regardless of finish, what you are suggesting would defeat the entire purpose of the thread.

And speaking of "on top", the $30 winner in Bill V.'s most recent post was "on top" at the first fraction, "on top" at the second fraction" and "on top" at the second call. The purpose behind this thread was to show how horses that are "on top" at these positions of the race are oft times "ON TOP" at the end of the race....regardless of their previous finish.

For the Lead….

You are one of the few posters on this board whose messages I value and respect. This demeanor of yours in this post seems out of character. It was not my intention to change the focus of this thread or to twist the thread. I was focused on presenting an idea when the opportunity presented itself….I was not thinking about your thread or your focus on this topic…..

There are many ways to dissect an issue….nothing is dogmatic or is set in stone….More than one way to skin a cat….anyways…..

I will always look forward to your posts….since I value your opinions on this open and public board…..

Cheers

For The Lead 02-02-2013 12:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lone speed (Post 88587)
For the Lead….

You are one of the few posters on this board whose messages I value and respect. This demeanor of yours in this post seems out of character. It was not my intention to change the focus of this thread or to twist the thread. I was focused on presenting an idea when the opportunity presented itself….I was not thinking about your thread or your focus on this topic…..

There are many ways to dissect an issue….nothing is dogmatic or is set in stone….More than one way to skin a cat….anyways…..

I will always look forward to your posts….since I value your opinions on this open and public board…..

Cheers

I apologize if I offended you in any way.

lone speed 02-02-2013 12:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by For The Lead (Post 88589)
I apologize if I offended you in any way.


For the Lead...

None taken....:)

As I said...you are one of the few posters whose opinions I valued...I have saved many of your postings and ideas that you have presented in my personal files to research and to utilize in this endeavor...We are in this forum to learn and to advance our personal skills and mindsets to enhance our knowledge and roi's...


Please continue your valued posts.....:cool:

Bill V. 02-02-2013 02:17 PM

Lone Speed
 
4 Attachment(s)
Hello LS

I suppose we can make a new paceline but in essence thats not needed
here.

Some lessons I have picked up from FTL

1. "Can't anybody bet a horse unless the program they're using tells them the horse is the FASTEST horse based on final time??"

2. The winner here owns the F1 , Turn Time and EPR Dream races
fractions.

3 If a horse can win from position 8 5 2 1 in one match up why can't a horse in the correct match up win with positions 1 2 5 8 ?

From Doc Sartin

Look at the 3 calls of Phase 1 not just the TPR
Look for a acceptable balance between EP and FF
Know what a winners 3rd fraction pararameters are at the tracks you wager
by class level, high Medium and Average
This was a low level MC race at 5.5


Even with the pace line as is Thoromation gets the 4 horse

Here are some screens
I have made 4 stop action screens On thoromation The 4 wins the race
but at the very last instint the 3 horses bunch up to look like a 3 horse
dead heat

But look at the race in thoromation at the 3 calls and take note of the
advantage early the 4 has

Attachment 33596

Attachment 33595

Attachment 33597


Attachment 33598

lone speed 02-02-2013 05:39 PM

Bill...


As usual, thank you for taking the time to posyt the screenshots of Thoromation...

I shouldn't have interjected this thread...my post was more about concept...I should have started a different thread....this horse was 14 to one because the public seemed fixated on the finish and beaten lengths at the finish line...

As I have posted in another thread, the horse the sets the pace of a race is always the one who expended the most energy....I have zero problems betting a horse who seem to falter in the stretch after setting a blitzing early fractions. I have focused many years researching the early matchup but with a different twist with Bradshaw's matchup principles as a guide...



I appreciate your time teaching and showing examples here immensely...

Sincerely,

Lone speed

Fwiw,I had chose my screen name deliberately, as I will always seek a race where there is a lone speed on the front end of a race.....

nysbill 02-10-2013 11:43 AM

Maiden Races Can be very good, very profitable plays
 
Maiden races containing a number of first time starters can be lucrative. Will a 1st tmr win? The only way to tell is to have reliable pace, speed, and pedigree data. If the runners in a maiden race that have raced have very low speed #s and no extenuating circumstances to explain them then a 1st tmr is where to look. If anyone is interested in greater detail reach me and I'll take the time to provde my insight.

Bill Lyster 02-10-2013 12:32 PM

3 Attachment(s)
In a field with six first time starters and 3 who had some experience, the fastest early paid over 7:1

Thanks FTL

Bill V. 02-10-2013 01:51 PM

Sleep
 
Hi Bill L

Hey Bill, you know were I hang out at Surfside at Del Mar
I'm sitting with the SA monitor right in front of me.

I watch this 7 horse win and only then when I see 7/1 do I look at the race
A LONE E8 7-1 !!!!!!

Asleep at the wheel !!

Bill If you throw out the 1 off over 150 days
it even make the race easier !

GS
Bill

lone speed 02-10-2013 07:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill V. (Post 88699)
Hi Bill L

Hey Bill, you know were I hang out at Surfside at Del Mar
I'm sitting with the SA monitor right in front of me.

I watch this 7 horse win and only then when I see 7/1 do I look at the race
A LONE E8 7-1 !!!!!!

Asleep at the wheel !!

Bill If you throw out the 1 off over 150 days
it even make the race easier !

GS
Bill

Doc Sartin always wrote in the follow up that our inner voice is just as important as the readouts in front of us....We must strive to control our "self talk" as sometimes we may find ourselves caught in web with our inner voices.....

It doesn't matter, Bill....at least you are aware of what kind of races and the model of the match up that you are looking for....(the Lone E-8 runner in a maiden race)

Repetition of successful patterns....

Looking forward to your next successful post....

Good skills

For The Lead 02-10-2013 09:20 PM

Maiden races at TP and SA
 
4 Attachment(s)
Good job by Bill L hitting that maiden winner and “thanks” for posting it up here.

I had 5 cards on my plate for yesterday, PRX, LRL, PEN, SA and TP. Unfortunately, PRX cancelled. Just as unfortunate, LRL had no maiden races, so I was left with SA, TP and PEN, so I thought I would post all the maiden races. Keep in mind, I do not do turf races, so I was left with a total of 8 maiden races. Also keep in mind, this thread was about “early” horses in maiden races.

The results are, there were 4 winners from these 8 races. Here are the prices of those 4 winners;

TP 2nd $15.80
SA 7th $17.00
PEN 4th $12.40
PEN 8th $12.60
The total return comes to $57.80.

If you played two horses per race, even where it wasn’t necessary, and based on a flat bet of $2 on each horse, your investment would have been $32.00, giving you a profit of $25.80. That’s an ROI of almost 81%. Not bad.

I’ll comment very briefly on the races where the winner was not among the contenders and post screen shots where the winner was among the contenders.

In the second race at TP there were 6 contenders, therefore it would make sense for two horse bettors to play the two early types.
Attachment 33618
Attachment 33619

In the 9th race at TP there were just 3 contenders. None of them won.

In the 5th race at SA there were just 3 contenders. None of them won.

In the 7th race at SA there were just 2 contenders. It is clear that just one of these horses were of the early type, so I really see no need to bet 2 horses.
Attachment 33620
Attachment 33621

In the 10th race at SA there were just 3 contenders. None of them won.

For The Lead 02-10-2013 09:25 PM

Maiden races at PEN
 
4 Attachment(s)
In the 1st race at PEN there were just 3 contenders. None of them won.


In the 4th race at PEN there were just 3 contenders. Here are the screen shots.
Attachment 33622
Attachment 33623


In the 8th race at PEN there were 4 contenders. with 4 contenders I guess it makes sense for the two horse bettors to bet the two early types.
Attachment 33624
Attachment 33625

ray lopez 02-13-2013 03:10 AM

FTL, what if the horse that is projected to be the on the lead at the 1st call is also the projected leader at the second call? Will you just bet that one horse to win ? or do you bet a second horse to win also ? How do you look for a second-horse-win-bet?
Thanks.

Ray

For The Lead 02-13-2013 11:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ray lopez (Post 88710)
FTL, what if the horse that is projected to be the on the lead at the 1st call is also the projected leader at the second call? Will you just bet that one horse to win ? or do you bet a second horse to win also ? How do you look for a second-horse-win-bet?
Thanks.

Ray

Many times the horse that has the lead at the first call is projected as the leader at the second call. This is common place. However, the best case scenario is for a horse to have the best first fraction (first call) time AND the best second fraction time. Obviously, this horse will show as having the best first fraction time AND the best second call time, but understand the difference. Don't lose sight of the fact that this is the best case scenario and not the only scenario in which the first fraction horse can go on to win.

Having the best first fraction time is self explanatory.
Having the best second fraction time means that this same early horse is running faster (or at the same pace) than all the horses behind it. When this is true, the horses attempting to make up ground on the leader is impossible. They just can't make up any ground if the leader isn't slowing down. In this scenario, the horse on the lead has a huge advantage.

RDSS provides the means to see these different scenarios. On the "segments screen" there are a couple of sections. One shows the computerized beaten lengths. This is at the first call (F1) AND the second call.
The section to the right of this shows the first fraction (F1) AND the second fraction (F2). The best second fraction (F2) horse could be any horse in the race. It could be the horse running dead last at the first call or it could be the horse on the lead at the first call or any horse in between. Where you see a horse that is last in the computed beaten lengths section at F1 and first for F2 in the incremental match up area, this does not mean this horse now has the lead at the second call. It only means it was running the fastest during the second fraction.

As far as how I bet, I am a one horse bettor. I either get it right with one horse or I don't. I spent many years as a one horse bettor, then I found the Sartin Methodology. At that point I became a two horse bettor in order to follow the methodology concepts. Later I went back to betting one horse.

If you look at my last post, right above your post, take a look at the 7th race at SA. There were only two contenders. It is obvious that only one of those two horses are of the early type and since an early type is the focus of the thread, you only need to bet that one horse. Now, if you are uncomfortable with only betting one horse, then bet both horses, I just feel the second bet is not worthwhile.

Finally, look at the the post of the 8th race at PEN.
In this race there are 4 contenders. If you look at the "computed beaten lengths" area it is easy to see that the #5 horse is the fastest first fraction horse. And as I stated above, this horse is also projected as the fastest "second call" horse. However, if you look to the right in the "incremental match up" area, you can see that the fastest second fraction horse is the #1 horse. Now look back at the "computed beaten lengths" area. You can see under the second call section that although the #5 shows best at the second call, the #1 is only 0.40 (less than 1/2 length) behind the leader. Notice that these two horses have a clear advantage over the other two horses at that point in the race. If the #5 does not go on to win, which horse is in the best position to win the race turning for home? The #1 and therefore the #1 would be your second bet.

I hope this helps.

Bill V. 02-14-2013 08:39 PM

Penn Race 1 Valentine gift
 
4 Attachment(s)
Here are the PP's and my comments
this is race 1 Penn 2/14/13
Attachment 33632
Attachment 33633
Attachment 33634
Attachment 33635


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:25 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.