Pace and Cap  - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up

Pace and Cap - Sartin Methodology & The Match Up (http://paceandcap.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Discussion (http://paceandcap.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   The predictive e/l balance (http://paceandcap.com/forums/showthread.php?t=5022)

Tim Y 01-09-2009 12:40 PM

The predictive e/l balance
 
"The weighted difference between the 2nd call and final fraction."

This simple number, particularly when studied throughout a specific horse's past performances, can tell a lot about the form cycle, the animal's usual running style, it's maturity, it's ability to handle certain distances and/or surfaces, can help you spot an isolated BIG MOVE that usually does not repeat (which happens all the time when a pace collapses or is so slow to the second call that the said runner has tons left) AND when used in evaluating those in a single field of runners (e/l relativity, and angle first introduced here last year), and help to eliminate those runners that are going to be too far out of the pace scenario to logically "get up" in time. It also allows formation of a track model for each distance.

The use on babies alone is fantastic. In one of the Follow Ups the median percent of all of Secretariat's races was presented and as this great one matured, the median went DOWN. That, along with what I observed by working with trainers, started my observing how babies learn to run. The final status of this observation was the 2nd call maiden: a horse that is telling you it is learning how to spread out it's speed and graduating by running the quickest to the 2nd call in it's previous or next to last race. Few babies (other than the great ones) learn late moves early in their DIRT races. In first steps toward getting out of the maiden ranks, these types learn to apportion their speed.

Young horses in their quest to approach longer distances will tell you that they have an upper limit to their abilities by an ever increasing e/l number. Hard Spun was classic in this regard never quite getting a step past 9 furlongs. Many many young ones, heading to the Kentucky Derby can be eliminated this way.

Track Bias: the e/l is a remarkable tool, when kept on a race to race basis, in prediciting if your track is showing a bias, and to what degree. This has worked fantastically at Churchill when the e/l of Oak's Day sets up the e/l for that first Saturday in May. At real speed favoring ovals like Aqu, Fe and Oaklawn, following it during the first few races, it can predict how the remainder of a card is going to run, or at courses that REALLY HAVE A BIG SWING in e/l (Woodbine) it can save you a lot of money and frustration.

Charlie D 01-10-2009 12:21 AM

Lets use our imagination and say, for whatever reason Street Sense takes no part in 2008 KD, who wins ??? Hard Spun probably


So, in using above, we have shown, the e/l predictive, the track played little part in the outcome of the 2007 KD

So what did determine the outcome of the 2007 KD ??? The Street Sense v Hard Spun v The rest of the feild MATCH UP


Take the 2008 KD, what determined Big Brown winning??? The Match Up of BB (a superior horse) v the rest (inferior horses)

Track does not even enter the equation does it, Why?? because it has very little influence on the outcome

Bill V. 01-10-2009 08:22 AM

The Sartin Methodology
 
Good points Charlie

That is why with the Sartin Methodology
We enter lines from the horses past performance lines
instead of from the result charts

We use the horses past performance to determine what will happen
in todays Match Up

Tim Y 01-10-2009 01:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Charlie D (Post 46337)


So, in using above, we have shown, the e/l predictive, the track played little part in the outcome of the 2007 KD

So what did determine the outcome of the 2007 KD ??? The Street Sense v Hard Spun v The rest of the feild MATCH UP


Take the 2008 KD, what determined Big Brown winning??? The Match Up of BB (a superior horse) v the rest (inferior horses)

Track does not even enter the equation does it, Why?? because it has very little influence on the outcome

MALARKEY

I cut my teeth on West Coast tracks starting about the time of Tim Tam's K Derby. I heard all the talk about bias and, having few, if any days effecting racing where I followed it (Hollywood's Summer meet boasted continuous fast tracks for over 8 years at one point), thought that bias was a pipe dream.

I started modeling tracks and shifted EAST. Once I did this, I could predict, almost to the day,when DEEP maintenance of the track had taken place at almost any venue. I would often talk to our maintenance crew here in town between races and throw out statements like:"You guys either dug up the track or added a lot of topsoil to it two days ago." THE RESPONSE? "How did you know that, you weren't here?"

I follow the e/l proclivities of EACH winning horse's pp's throughout each program. Most days, the logical horses do their logical thing. BUT when it is wet and particularly when it is cold, the winning pp e/l's move positively to the point of my discovery of the angle STYLE (e/l) over SUBSTANCE (total energy) hits with uncanny repetition. When there is a strong biased course (i.e Bellamy Road's Wood Memorial victory) NOTHING not on the front end of the e/l range wins. NOTHING. I know a fellow who worked with the track crew THAT particular day, and he reported that they brought in tons of sand and rolled the track to the point, as he stated "It was like a pave road and NOTHING off the pace had a chance."

IF this observation were an isolated one, that would be one thing, BUT many others have found EXACTLY WHAT I FOUND and have profited substantially from it. One of the best applications of this is when a shipper comes in from an "opposite" course (i.e FG to Aqu) and, if they are the favorite, AND the e/l is predicting it's bias, it is an easy choice to TOTALLY eliminate them. The e/l alone eliminated many a low ODDS colt in the Derby: Sweetnothernsaint, Pyro. Stormello, Bob n'John, NoBiz, Bellamy Road etc. etc.

I have been following the e/l of all the races on K Oaks day now for 6 years. The maintenance crew is famous for manipulating the track there so when it is biased Friday, it carries over to Saturday. The year Giacomo won, all the speed on Friday (including one UNDEFEATED front running sprinter that towered over her field, BACKED UP significantly) versus the year Funny Cide won on the first Saturday in May, the Oaks winner (with a high positive e/l) went wire to wire by open lengths. I find the correlation MORE than significant.

Year after year, I have followed the rising e/l, and percent medians of many of the three year olds heading toward the Derby and NONE of them with a steadily rising e/l, NOT A ONE, did a thing at 10 furlongs at Churchill...NOT A ONE.

The track bias is NOT universal, but my study on e/l relativity (substantiated by 5 independent studies) shows that it is predictive to the point that one can eliminate several. (often favorites) from field after field. Terry (a great handicapper from Minnesota) and I made an absolute KILLING at Woodbine using just this angle: horses that NEVER hung on were winning race after race in late November there. That bias hung on for three days in -10 degree weather with winds until they canceled. It was real and repetitive.

Your inexperience in showing YET again as the SAME thing will happen again this year as the colts head toward Churchill as it has for as many years as I have followed it.

Tim Y 01-10-2009 01:35 PM

1 Attachment(s)
what are the e/l's in AQU's opener?

JUST playing it alone predicted the exacta

FIT THE E/L of the HORSE to the E/L model of the TRACK just as E/L relativity predicts YET AGAIN

Charlie D 01-10-2009 01:43 PM

Everything that differs from Tims view seems to be Malarkey


No point putting up an opposing view really is there

Tim Y 01-10-2009 01:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Charlie D (Post 46362)
Everything that differs from Tims view seems to be Malarkey


No point putting up an opposing view really is there

Wel since I have TONS of substantiation for years, and YOU have NONE, which one do you think an OBJECTIVE third party might accept?

BRING forth DATA to show that differing point of view and THEN and only then will that differing position have ANY VALIDITY AT ALL

Opinion doesn't cut it in a rational debate

Tim Y 01-10-2009 01:58 PM

1 Attachment(s)
2nd race today at AQU goes to the e/l winners

Charlie D 01-10-2009 01:58 PM

The Street Sense's , Curlin's, Big Brown's, Zarakava's, etc, etc v rest tells you the Match Up decides



And the third parties can read and decide for themselves can't they

Tim Y 01-10-2009 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Charlie D (Post 46367)
The Street Sense's , Curlin's, Big Brown's, Zarakava's, etc, etc v rest tells you the Match Up decides



And the third parties can read and decide for themselves can't they

you have little to no historical perspective to draw on if that is as far back as your racing knowledge takes you.

Horses way way back have told the same tale: early has a big advantage and the e/l predicts it over and over..

Using champions to make your argument leaves oput about 99% of all the horses running today and yesterday

Bill V. 01-10-2009 02:28 PM

Yes
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Charlie D (Post 46362)
Everything that differs from Tims view seems to be Malarkey


No point putting up an opposing view really is there

Charlie .. I will
This is the heart of the Sartin Methodology

Its all mainstream The crowd loves this , Early is were its at.. Look for early
The horse will go out to the lead and never look back
Mainstream

I will stand firm that no single readout is were its al
The horse runs the race in todays match up

For every example posted of this or that readout producing winners
I will put in the same lines and do very well using the top 5 Primary line score and total energy lines and using
5 Sartin Methodology readouts

1 VDC
2. Total Energy
3. Balance
4. FX
5. The Early Late graph

Bill

xtb 01-10-2009 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Y (Post 46364)
Wel since I have TONS of substantiation for years, and YOU have NONE, which one do you think an OBJECTIVE third party might accept?

BRING forth DATA to show that differing point of view and THEN and only then will that differing position have ANY VALIDITY AT ALL

Opinion doesn't cut it in a rational debate


Tim, can you please provide us with the data from yours and/or the 5 independent studies you referred to earlier, so that we can draw our own conclusions? Thank you.

Charlie D 01-10-2009 02:40 PM

You can use any race you like Tim

The result is mainly down to the influence of the horse v horse v horse Match Up

Tim Y 01-10-2009 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Charlie D (Post 46380)
You can use any race you like Tim

The result is mainly down to the influence of the horse v horse v horse Match Up

A novice without ANY data can say that with conviction but the data predicts differently

Lots of it is coming it is on some older CD's I have to access.

I am awaiting ANYTHING that would substantiate otherwise, but that is never going to happen.

I see this growing trend in the populous to fall into the trap of Nonscientific acceptance of erroneous ideas like foot reflexology based upon nonsense but promoted as fact even though reams of data proved that it is totally bogus. Indicative of a nonthinking populous.

Tim Y 01-10-2009 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xtb (Post 46377)
Tim, can you please provide us with the data from yours and/or the 5 independent studies you referred to earlier, so that we can draw our own conclusions? Thank you.

they are all at Sartin Alums from many sources: Terry, Jack, Dylan, Earl etc. find them yourself

Tim Y 01-10-2009 03:45 PM

1 Attachment(s)
fifth race is a repeat

th race - Aqueduct - January 10, 2009
Pgm Horse Win Place Show
7 The Vin Man 19.00 10.40 6.50
4 Holly Time 6.60 4.30
11 Golden Man 4.10

Tim Y 01-10-2009 03:50 PM

[QUOTE=Bill V.;46376]Charlie .. I will
This is the heart of the Sartin Methodology

Its all mainstream The crowd loves this , Early is were its at.. Look for early
The horse will go out to the lead and never look back
Mainstream

Bill I am afraid that you don't even have mainstream correctly: they are all POSTIONISTS not energy distribution advocates

tom 01-10-2009 04:00 PM

That is exactly what he said - go to the front and not look back. That is positional. :rolleyes:

Myself, I would really like to see just one of these mysterious "studies" that are oft mentioned yet never seen.

Aqu 1st today - won by the top Beyer fig horse, place horse there on class. Only three horses figured to meet the race conditions - 4,5,6. There were two of them at the wire. No pace was needed in that one.

Tim Y 01-10-2009 04:01 PM

here is another that the e/l promoted as posted at alums last year

"Emma Jayne has a shot to steal the Queen's Plate tomorrow with Mike
Fox but Jiggs Coz and Wakefield will be running at her late. The two
year old champ Leonnatus had % medians that look like a turfer or 12
furlong colt.....


let's see how it goes."


Paid over 30 dollars

and one of the advocates who had substantiated that same study responded:

"Great call! My only wager of the day - after watching the claimers in
the race prior to the Queens Plate run the half in 44.1 and finish 6.5f
in 115.99, only .06 off the track record, it was clear the fix was on
for the speed to have a chance to win the Plate
. The 2C horses ran
1,2,3!
tk

or a third e/l devotee piped in:

"This is # 4 - another Tip from you, that I did not listen too.

Nice picking, I would like to pick your brain sometime about this pick.

Please let me know when you are free to chat.

Jack"

xtb 01-10-2009 04:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Y (Post 46386)
they are all at Sartin Alums from many sources: Terry, Jack, Dylan, Earl etc. find them yourself

About what I expected.

xtb 01-10-2009 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Y (Post 46391)
here is another that the e/l promoted as posted at alums last year

"Emma Jayne has a shot to steal the Queen's Plate tomorrow with Mike
Fox but Jiggs Coz and Wakefield will be running at her late. The two
year old champ Leonnatus had % medians that look like a turfer or 12
furlong colt.....


let's see how it goes."


Paid over 30 dollars

and one of the advocates who had substantiated that same study responded:

"Great call! My only wager of the day - after watching the claimers in
the race prior to the Queens Plate run the half in 44.1 and finish 6.5f
in 115.99, only .06 off the track record, it was clear the fix was on
for the speed to have a chance to win the Plate
. The 2C horses ran
1,2,3!
tk

or a third e/l devotee piped in:

"This is # 4 - another Tip from you, that I did not listen too.

Nice picking, I would like to pick your brain sometime about this pick.

Please let me know when you are free to chat.

Jack"

Not saying that there isn't anything to your e/l but it's not the only way to win. Winning examples mean nothing if you aren't also showing the losers, I'm sure you and your buddies don't crow when it fails.

Tim Y 01-10-2009 04:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xtb (Post 46396)
Not saying that there isn't anything to your e/l but it's not the only way to win. Winning examples mean nothing if you aren't also showing the losers, I'm sure you and your buddies don't crow when it fails.

NEVER said that: it has to be used when it is apparent that it is relevant

Bill V. 01-10-2009 04:19 PM

No Tim
 
[QUOTE=Tim Y;46388]
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill V. (Post 46376)
Charlie .. I will
This is the heart of the Sartin Methodology

Its all mainstream The crowd loves this , Early is were its at.. Look for early
The horse will go out to the lead and never look back
Mainstream

Bill I am afraid that you don't even have mainstream correctly: they are all POSTIONISTS not energy distribution advocates

That is true The mainstream is looking at 1's and 2's in the DRF
Not the amount of difference between the horse early and late energy
BTW

Good Job with race 2 from Aqu
Tim Putting in your same lines from race 2
Using The Sartin Methodology Program endourced
by Howard Satin in the val 4 mode

Line
Horse 1 lines 1-3 Line 4 is out 15 Beaten Lengths in the mud!
Horse 2 Line 1
Horse 3 Line 3
Horse 5 Line 1-3 Line 3 is out 11 Beaten Lengths
Horse 6 Line 1
Horse 7 Line 1-3
Horse 8 Line 1
horse 10 line 1 Out over 7.5 Beaten Lengths

Hiding to the top 5 Primary/ Total Energy
the first hide is line 1 for the 7 as line 3 is better
the next hide is the 2
the next hide is the 8

My final contenders using your pacelines using val 4 as
per Doc's guidelines are
3 5 1 7 6

VDC readout has
3-1
5-2
1-3
7-2
6-5

The winner of the race is # 6 $11.00
No matter how I do the race the winner is not in my top 5
Very well done. I am wrong in this case

Bill

xtb 01-10-2009 04:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Y (Post 46397)
NEVER said that: it has to be used when it is apparent that it is relevant

Like many things, it works! (except when it doesn't).

Tim Y 01-10-2009 04:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xtb (Post 46400)
Like many things, it works! (except when it doesn't).

As per usual your miss the point of how it is used: IT is a race to race, day to day observation ONLY BROUGHT TO PROMINANCE when that day's results prompt you to make it mainstream.

As for the colts streching out, it is accurate all the time.

Wait until the Derby colts start sorting themselves out

Tim Y 01-10-2009 04:28 PM

1 Attachment(s)
[QUOTE=Bill V.;46398]
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Y (Post 46388)

That is true The mainstream is looking at 1's and 2's in the DRF
Not the amount of difference between the horse early and late energy
BTW

Good Job with race 2 from Aqu
Tim Putting in your same lines from race 2
Using The Sartin Methodology Program endourced
by Howard Satin in the val 4 mode

Line
Horse 1 lines 1-3 Line 4 is out 15 Beaten Lengths in the mud!
Horse 2 Line 1
Horse 3 Line 3
Horse 5 Line 1-3 Line 3 is out 11 Beaten Lengths
Horse 6 Line 1
Horse 7 Line 1-3
Horse 8 Line 1
horse 10 line 1 Out over 7.5 Beaten Lengths

Hiding to the top 5 Primary/ Total Energy
the first hide is line 1 for the 7 as line 3 is better
the next hide is the 2
the next hide is the 8

My final contenders using your pacelines using val 4 as
per Doc's guidelines are
3 5 1 7 6

VDC readout has
3-1
5-2
1-3
7-2
6-5

The winner of the race is # 6 $11.00
No matter how I do the race the winner is not in my top 5
Very well done. I am wrong in this case

Bill

one of the main reason I abandonded Validator: it locks you into a specific way of looking at a race and leaves no room for alternate logic as the e.l shows here

Bill V. 01-10-2009 04:49 PM

The
 
Funny thing Tim
Thats exactly why I stay with Validator

If I worked races like you I would be broke because I don't have your
ability to interpret
What works for each user is the most important
Thanks for your work ups. I am finding it very helpful, We all are going to have
some loses in our 20 race cycle, Doing some post mortem as Doc suggest
I find your work here refreshing as to perhaps reasons why loses while following guidelines still happen
Please continue but also please once again refer to the Pace and Cap
code of conduct and treat my and your fellow guest in my
house with respect and they will do the same to you

bobp 01-13-2009 12:42 AM

I for one would be interested to hear how any of you in the above discussion consider
how these would apply in your equation

1. class drops
2. recency
3. previous race on this course
4. top 5 trainer at this course in this race
5. record keeping for the course you play

Tim Y 01-13-2009 12:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bobp (Post 46553)
I for one would be interested to hear how any of you in the above discussion consider
how these would apply in your equation

1. class drops HORSES DONT KNOW WHO THEY ARE RUNNING AGAINST
2. recency doesn't matter speed is either ON or OFF
3. previous race on this course
4. top 5 trainer at this course in this race HORSE is running not trainer
5. record keeping for the course you play

THE KEY is the fifth one


The early/late is all about the HORSE'S energy distribution and is INHERENT to the physiology under stress of pace pressure

Tim Y 01-13-2009 01:16 AM

This data was accumulated and evaluated in complete absence of any factor that the HORSE did not do.

Horses do the running. Situational pace stress can alter energy distribution but is ultimately INNATE to the animal and not much else other than when a bias aides/hinders that expression.

They win/lose based upon THEIR effort, THEIR form cycle, THEIR physiology, THEIR genetic expression of energy distribution. One cannot adequately evaluate anything else objectively but the innate hard wired expression of energy distribution via segmental velocity, which is there all the time, and doesn't vary much other than the top 1% of animals that we called champions: they adapt to anything.

Overlying a subsidiary human element will not change the inherent nature of the horse.

Charlie D 01-13-2009 03:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bobp (Post 46553)
I for one would be interested to hear how any of you in the above discussion consider
how these would apply in your equation

1. class drops
2. recency
3. previous race on this course
4. top 5 trainer at this course in this race
5. record keeping for the course you play




1, Class designations like Clm20, Alw50 are not as good at measuring Class/ability as Pace, speed, ratings analysis, so i use those and ignore race conditions

2, can be a good indicator of current condition, ability

3, Of little relevance imo unless it is a surface switch, then it may become an issue

4, Of little relevance, it's the horse that matters not trainer %

5, The only records that matter are your betting records


This Great Game is about Horse V Horse V Horse V Horse - The Match Up

tom 01-13-2009 09:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bobp (Post 46553)
I for one would be interested to hear how any of you in the above discussion consider
how these would apply in your equation

1. class drops - A key factor, IMHO.......but not just droppers - there has to be so analysis about the drop. In this example, Bill going back for that paceline was fully justified after a good class analysis
2. recency - not the big deal it used to be
3. previous race on this course - I think it a peripheral factor, maybe to separate two closely rated horses at it's best.
4. top 5 trainer at this course in this race - I will be more willing to go back in the PPs with a good trainer than a poor one
5. record keeping for the course you play A key thing. My records tell me that at this lowest level - $7500 Clmg at AQU - many horses are coming off dismal efforts and dropping from better races in the past, at higher classes. This winner was a text book example of that, if you put his drop into context.

My two cents bolded.

bobp 01-13-2009 09:49 AM

thanks for your responses guys.
My tedious record keeping has opened my eyes to
many correlations of tracks, trainers, and energy distribution.
Seems like we have differences on some issues and total agreement on others. Could be ones comfort zone in the winning process and habits.

There always seems to be lots of good info here if one just thinks about how it applies to his style and programm.

Tims comment on record keeping is the key for me.

Best for everyone in 2009 . LOOK FOR THE POSITIVEBob;)

bobp 01-13-2009 05:07 PM

Class Drops
 
In response to some of the replys to mine:

Check out the Florida circuit for the past two weeks.

[B]And the horse may do the running, but the trainer makes the entry in todays race. Results dont lie
/B]Bob:)

Tim Y 01-13-2009 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bobp (Post 46599)
In response to some of the replys to mine:

Check out the Florida circuit for the past two weeks.

[B]And the horse may do the running, but the trainer makes the entry in todays race. Results dont lie
/B]Bob:)

When does the trainer run the race? the farrier? the groom? the owner?

What entity is timed through the course of a run?

Which entity breaks the beam at each call?

It is like saying that a great performance in a play is due to the actor's manager, sound technician or make up artist....silly

correlation? never cause and effect


The only value in looking at a horse's performance is in the field it competes NOT some arbitrary subjective horse VALUE

Tim Y 01-13-2009 05:36 PM

This reminds me of the famous cancer cluster experiment that we all learned about in graduate school as a prime example of poor experiemental design.

In Scandinavia cancer clusters were studied and a certain percentage were found approximately close to high tension wires. Questioning " cause and effect" another researcher simply looked at ALL incidences of the same cancer and found that hundreds of children NO WHERE near high tension wires got the disease and hundreds upon hundreds who lived in the same proximity to the wires were healthy.

bad experimental design brings out flawed understanding. Same here as those peripheral aspects have nothing to do with the running of a horse or the match up it faced.

Tim Y 01-13-2009 06:46 PM

inner shift
 
Once the haven of the pronounced e/l, THIS season, so far it has drifted down for sprints being in the range of +2 to +10

bobp 01-13-2009 07:15 PM

Fyi
 
Talk about Silly Not one horse runs a race unless the trainer reads the conditions and makes the entry. End of story

tom 01-14-2009 08:45 AM

And gets the horse ready to run.

Do the crews not make or break the Indy car?
It is a no brainer to say the horse does the running,
It also a no brainer to say the horse trains himself, enters himself, etc.

Bill's going back 5 lines on his winner is a perfect example of this.

bobp 01-14-2009 12:30 PM

RE: Trainers
 
Tom, thanks for the common sense reply. sometimes we get Superfulous Nonsense.

Bob


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.